Home-Knowledge-

Content

Silicon Steel: Grades, Properties and Core Selection Guide

Jan 31, 2024

What Silicon Steel Is and Why Silicon Is Added

Silicon steel is a ferrosilicon alloy made with very low carbon content and a silicon addition between roughly 0.5% and 4.5%. Silicon is added because it raises the electrical resistivity of the iron lattice, which suppresses eddy current loss, reduces hysteresis loss by lowering coercivity, and improves permeability. Those magnetic gains come at a cost: silicon increases hardness and brittleness, so a higher silicon content makes the strip harder to cold roll and to punch.

Carbon, sulfur, nitrogen and oxygen are held to very low levels because each of them interferes with grain growth and raises loss. The entire production route, from steelmaking through hot rolling, cold rolling, annealing and coating, exists to deliver a clean, correctly textured strip with a stable core loss value.

Grain-Oriented and Non-Oriented Families

The two families differ in grain structure, and that structure determines where each can be used.

Characteristic Grain-oriented Non-oriented
Grain structure Grains aligned with the rolling direction through secondary recrystallisation, giving the Goss texture Grains randomly oriented with uniform magnetic properties in all directions
Magnetic behaviour Strongly anisotropic. Best properties along the rolling direction, poorer across it Isotropic, so the same loss in every direction
Silicon content Around 3% Typically 0.5% up to about 3.2%
Typical thickness 0.23 mm to 0.35 mm 0.35 mm to 0.65 mm
Main duty Transformer cores where flux is unidirectional Motors, generators and rotating machines where flux rotates

The choice is not a quality ranking. Oriented steel is the better material for a flux path that never changes direction, and non-oriented steel is the better material for a flux path that rotates, no matter how good the oriented grade is.

Grade Designations, Standards and Test Methods

Chinese designations under GB/T 2521.2 for non-oriented product give the nominal thickness in millimetres, the letter W for non-oriented, and the maximum specific loss multiplied by one hundred. A 50W470 grade is therefore 0.50 mm thick with a maximum specific loss of 4.70 W/kg at the standardised condition of 1.5 T and 50 Hz, and a 35W300 grade is 0.35 mm thick with a maximum loss of 3.00 W/kg. Loss values fall as thickness falls, which is why thin gauge grades are used where frequency is high.

Oriented grades under GB/T 2521.1 use the letter Q instead, so a 30Q120 grade is 0.30 mm thick with a maximum loss of 1.20 W/kg, tested at the higher induction of 1.7 T and 50 Hz. Oriented product is also classified by polarisation at 800 A/m, with conventional grades at around 1.80 T and above and high magnetic induction grades above 1.88 T.

The international standards use parallel systems for the same materials, and each of them defines its own grade table, tolerances and coating types.

GB/T 2521.1 covers grain-oriented electrical steel, and GB/T 2521.2 covers non-oriented electrical steel, both giving grade tables, tolerances and coating types.

IEC 60404-8-7 specifies grain-oriented material and IEC 60404-8-4 specifies non-oriented material delivered in the fully processed state.

ASTM A876 covers grain-oriented and ASTM A677 non-oriented fully processed electrical steel, and JIS C 2552 covers non-oriented grades in the Japanese system.

Specific loss and polarisation are measured on an Epstein frame to IEC 60404-2 or on a single sheet tester to IEC 60404-3, and the method must be stated with the result because the two do not give identical numbers.

Surface insulation resistance is tested to IEC 60404-11, and coating adhesion, thickness tolerance, flatness and residual curvature are tested to the product standard.

Coatings, Cutting and Core Building

Silicon steel carries an insulating coating that limits inter-laminar eddy currents, protects the surface during handling and, in some oriented grades, applies tension that improves magnetic properties. Coating types are defined in the standard, and the type is chosen to suit the subsequent process, because some coatings survive a stress relief anneal and some do not.

Slitting and shearing produce burrs. Burr height should be kept low, typically below 0.02 mm, because burrs short adjacent laminations together and raise loss.

Punching and laser cutting introduce local stress and a heat affected zone, both of which raise loss near the cut line. Where loss matters, the cut edge is kept out of the high flux density region.

Non-oriented laminations for motors are often stress relief annealed after punching, typically at around 750 to 800 °C in a controlled atmosphere, which requires a coating that tolerates the treatment.

Stacking factor depends on lamination thickness and coating weight, so core weight calculations must use the actual stacking factor rather than the density of solid steel.

Supply, Tolerances and Quality Control

Magnetic properties are certified per production lot, with specific loss and polarisation reported at the standard test condition and thickness tolerance stated against the grade table.

Thickness is measured across the strip width and along the length, since a thickness deviation raises loss and disturbs stacking.

Coating thickness and inter-laminar resistance are checked for cores that will be annealed after winding or stacking.

Supply is by coil in slit widths or by cut lengths, and the order should state grade, thickness, width, coating type, core loss limit and certificate requirements.

Storage is indoors in dry, ventilated conditions with coils kept off the floor, because edge rust and moisture damage to the coating are not recoverable in processing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the difference between 50W470 and 30Q120?

A: The first is non-oriented, 0.50 mm thick with a maximum specific loss of 4.70 W/kg at 1.5 T and 50 Hz. The second is grain-oriented, 0.30 mm thick with a maximum loss of 1.20 W/kg at 1.7 T and 50 Hz.

Q: Why does a higher silicon content limit thickness reduction?

A: Silicon increases hardness and brittleness, so the strip becomes harder to cold roll without cracking and more prone to edge cracking during slitting. That is why very high silicon content is combined with specialised processing.

Q: Can non-oriented steel be used in a transformer?

A: Yes, for small and low cost transformers, but oriented steel delivers lower loss for the same flux density in a unidirectional core, so it is preferred wherever efficiency matters.

Q: Does the insulating coating affect core loss?

A: It does. Inter-laminar resistance controls eddy current loss in the stack, so a damaged or too thin coating raises loss even when the strip itself meets its grade.

Q: How should cut edges and punched features be treated?

A: They should be kept as clean and as low in burr as practical, and the affected zones should be placed away from high flux density areas, because cutting stress and burrs both increase local loss in service.

SEND INQUIRY

SEND INQUIRY